The Making of a Manager cover

The Making of a Manager

What to Do When Everyone Looks to You

Julie Zhuo 2025
Business & Economics

Press Enter to add

10

Key Takeaways

  1. 1

    Management is a learned skill, not an innate talent. Julie Zhuo emphasizes that many new managers feel unprepared because no one formally teaches them how to lead, yet competence comes through practice, feedback, and reflection. The discomfort of early leadership is normal and part of the growth process.

  2. 2

    A manager’s primary job is to get better outcomes from a team working together than from individuals working alone. This means focusing on communication, alignment, and removing obstacles rather than doing the work yourself. Success is measured by the team’s results, not personal productivity.

  3. 3

    Trust is the foundation of effective management. When team members trust their manager, they are more open, motivated, and willing to take risks. Building trust requires consistency, honesty, and genuine care for people’s growth.

  4. 4

    Good feedback is specific, actionable, and rooted in a desire to help others improve. Vague praise or criticism is far less effective than clear examples tied to observable behaviors. Managers should deliver feedback regularly, not just during formal reviews.

  5. 5

    Hiring well is one of the most important and high-leverage activities a manager can do. Thoughtful recruiting processes and clear role definitions increase the chances of long-term team success. A strong hire can elevate the entire team’s performance.

  6. 6

    One-on-one meetings are a critical tool for understanding and supporting team members. These meetings should prioritize the employee’s agenda, concerns, and development rather than just status updates. Consistent one-on-ones foster trust and uncover issues early.

  7. 7

    Culture is shaped by the behaviors that leaders tolerate and reward. Managers play a key role in modeling values and reinforcing norms through everyday decisions. Even small actions signal what truly matters within a team.

  8. 8

    Delegation is essential for scaling impact as a manager. Trying to control every detail limits team growth and creates bottlenecks. Effective delegation includes setting clear expectations, providing context, and granting autonomy.

  9. 9

    Decision-making improves when managers clarify goals and define what success looks like. Structured thinking, weighing trade-offs, and involving the right stakeholders help teams move forward confidently. Not every decision needs to be perfect, but it should be intentional.

  10. 10

    Managing former peers requires resetting expectations and boundaries. Clear communication about new responsibilities and maintaining fairness helps preserve relationships. Respect is earned through competence, transparency, and consistency rather than authority alone.

12

Concepts

The Manager’s Job

The core responsibility of a manager is to achieve better outcomes through a team than any individual could alone. This involves coaching, aligning, and supporting others rather than executing every task personally.

Example

Facilitating collaboration between designers and engineers to ship a feature on time Clarifying priorities so the team focuses on the most impactful work

Trust Building

Trust is developed through reliability, honesty, and genuine concern for team members’ well-being. It enables open communication and stronger performance.

Example

Following through on promised support for a promotion case Admitting a mistake openly to the team

Effective Feedback

Feedback should be timely, specific, and focused on behaviors rather than personal traits. Its goal is to help someone improve and succeed.

Example

Pointing out that a presentation lacked clear data to support claims Praising a team member for proactively resolving a customer issue

One-on-One Meetings

Regular one-on-one meetings provide dedicated time for managers to understand each team member’s challenges, goals, and concerns. They are essential for building relationships and offering support.

Example

Discussing career aspirations during a weekly check-in Identifying workload stress before burnout occurs

Hiring for Strength

Thoughtful hiring focuses on identifying candidates whose skills and values align with team needs. Strong hires elevate performance and shape culture.

Example

Designing structured interview questions tied to job competencies Involving multiple team members in candidate evaluation

Team Culture

Culture is defined by shared norms, values, and behaviors that guide how work gets done. Managers reinforce culture through what they reward and discourage.

Example

Recognizing collaboration publicly during team meetings Addressing disrespectful behavior immediately

Delegation

Delegation involves entrusting tasks and decisions to others while providing context and clarity. It increases team ownership and frees managers to focus on higher-level work.

Example

Assigning ownership of a product launch to a senior team member Allowing a direct report to run a client meeting independently

Managing Former Peers

Transitioning from peer to manager requires resetting expectations and establishing new boundaries. Clear communication and fairness help maintain respect.

Example

Explaining role changes in a team meeting after a promotion Avoiding favoritism toward former close colleagues

Decision-Making Frameworks

Structured approaches to decision-making clarify goals, constraints, and trade-offs. They help teams move forward with confidence even amid uncertainty.

Example

Listing pros and cons before choosing a product direction Defining success metrics before launching a new initiative

Performance Management

Performance management involves setting expectations, evaluating outcomes, and supporting improvement. It ensures alignment between individual contributions and team goals.

Example

Setting quarterly objectives with measurable targets Creating an improvement plan for an underperforming employee

Coaching Mindset

A coaching mindset focuses on developing people’s skills and judgment rather than simply giving orders. Managers ask questions and guide reflection to foster growth.

Example

Asking a team member how they would approach solving a recurring problem Providing stretch assignments to build new capabilities

Scaling Yourself

As responsibilities grow, managers must amplify their impact by empowering others. This means prioritizing high-leverage activities and resisting micromanagement.

Example

Creating documentation so the team can operate without constant oversight Training a team lead to handle day-to-day operational decisions